Tuesday, May 11, 2021

Parents: Scripture is Sufficient

I certainly never expected that I would fall into the trap of false teaching. I was raised in a Christian home with loving parents who took me to church, taught me Christian values, and even sacrificed to send me to a Christian school where I learned the Bible and practiced spiritual disciplines daily. I made the decision to follow Christ for myself at age 15 and never really went through the rebellious teenager stage. I have memorized Scripture and would estimate that I know probably 75% of the events that take place in the Bible. I married a Christ-following man after college and have continued to seek after the Lord and attend Bible-believing churches in the years since we have been married. I would have told you that there was no way I could have fallen into deception as far as what the Bible taught! And I would have been very wrong. Let me briefly tell you our story of becoming parents. 

My husband and I felt God’s leading to start the process to become foster parents in our mid-20s and we had never been in the role of “Mom and Dad” before. We had the willingness to parent kids from hard places, but very little experience. As we embarked on the journey of being parents to our first little one, we realized that not only did we have an instant toddler, walking, talking, running…(away from us in parking lots), we did not have the bonds that most parents and toddlers have who were biologically stitched together. We were getting a trial-by-fire introduction to parenting, and as most parents do, we needed some wisdom from those who had gone before us. Through our church and social media pages, we kept hearing about taking classes which help parents raise kids who have come from traumatic situations. We signed up and took a class over the course of six weeks. The classes we attended and books we read were full of good ideas. They equipped us with different strategies to engage children of all ages to exercise self-control and practice calmness and thoughtfulness. The idea was that over time, greater depths of discipline could be achieved as the child learned to operate inside a foundation built on trust and love for their parents- something that newborn babies all the way up to teenagers may not have experienced in their birth families. The classes helped us understand brain physiology and develop empathy and compassion for what trauma and abuse can do to a person and how to be more patient in training our children who are in foster care. The classes in and of themselves were helpful and gave us some tools to address the behaviors and needs of our children that we hadn’t considered before. 

Since we found the class to be helpful, I began to surround myself with other trauma-focused women through church, friendships, social media, podcasts, etc. I loved my life as a foster mom and was eager to glean wisdom from these older, wiser ladies that had a lot to say about raising children from traumatic situations. This is where the problems began. These older, “wiser” women, all of whom attended Bible-believing churches, many of whom were even pastors’ wives, never said anything to me about the Bible, other than to tell me that this way of parenting aligned to the Gospel. They never pointed me to the Scriptures or encouraged me to hold my children accountable for their sin. They never reminded me that only God could heal my children from their past abuse. They only pointed me to the “religion” of trauma-based parenting and its ideologies. Admittedly, I even pushed my husband into these ideologies as we tried to bring a unified approach to parenting in this way, as was the case for most of the couples that I had contact with over the years who were also in these circles. These ideologies were not explicitly taught but were intrinsic to the conversations, the memes, and the discussions on podcasts, social media pages, and during Mom's Coffee Night. Here are four of the most common ideas that I observed creeping into the minds and hearts of the women involved: 

1. You aren’t modeling God’s love and grace if you are unyielding in your expectations for your child’s behavior.

2. Kids misbehave because of the trauma they have experienced, and if they could make a better choice, they would. Therefore they don’t because they physiologically can’t.

3. If you don’t subscribe to and practice nearly everything produced by these parenting programs, you are not helping your child heal from their trauma (and might be making it worse).

4. You should identify your own “triggers” from childhood that might be causing you to take offense to your child’s wrong behaviors (you may never have known you had any triggers- getting counseling will “reveal” these to you.)

 As you can see, these ideas are not without spiritual implications. What started out as the desire to teach and train my children in a way that is conducive to reshaping their past experiences, quickly morphed into an expected lifestyle. Those pushing these ideologies employ a worldview which blames the parents’ hidden character flaws for a child’s misbehavior, places the weight of mental and emotional healing on the parents’ discipline efforts, and absolves kids almost completely of their sin simply because of their circumstances in life. Though my husband and I didn’t immerse ourselves fully in the practices that these “leaders” were pushing, as we continued to foster and eventually adopt, we regularly felt defeated in our attempts to parent the way we heard others in these circles were parenting. I tried to keep a mental checklist of what to do and what not to do based on the social media posts and heartfelt stories that I saw from those I thought were doing it “the right way.” I berated my husband when he didn’t handle something “right”, and beat myself up and felt like a terrible mother when I reverted back to the “less loving and gracious” way of parenting (which I did regularly). Our kids didn’t seem to really care about any of the non-punitive consequences that we attempted to enforce, and actually responded better to the way we were told not to parent, though we felt guilty for reverting back into some of these tendencies. We weren’t seeing the results we wanted to and ultimately we felt powerless as parents. 

Over the next couple of years, we started seeing that what we had considered to be resources, encouragement, and even discipleship were actually just lies. We unsubscribed from the social media, the podcasts, the church classes, etc. and ultimately unsubscribed our family from the ideologies making us weak, ineffective parents producing weak, excuse-filled children. We have now been foster and adoptive parents for several years and have had over a dozen children in and out of our home, adopting several of them. Our children are very happy, healthy, and successful at home and school and love the Lord. My husband and I argue less about the right way to handle something, we are more confident as parents and we are able to delight in our kids instead of wondering if we’re worsening their trauma. I am forever thankful to the faithfulness of God to eventually help us see that we had strayed from what He says is the right way to view misbehavior and the discipline of our children. Now, it is my mission to make sure that other moms, whether they are foster and adoptive moms or not, see parenting programs for what they can be: God-given resources to equip us to be godly parents, and what they are never to be: the indoctrination of a different worldview, seeing children as inherently sinless or as a product of their circumstances who want to do the right thing but can’t. 

Let me be clear, the reason that I fell into this pattern of wrong thinking was not because I didn’t know that the Bible said anything raising children. It is because I subconsciously did not consider Scripture to be the only valuable resource out there and I mistakenly placed my trust in the advice of women who marketed themselves as Gospel-centered trauma experts. Turns out their approach was very light on the Gospel. When I started to really believe that Scripture was solely sufficient for all issues in life, I understood that what I had been following were very covert lies. And I began to see everything outside of Scripture as either deception or a resource that is only useful if you are using it within the bounds of what God says in Scripture. 

Biblical discipline 

There are many verses in the Bible about parenting and discipline in general. Here are a few verses you may be familiar with: 

  • Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord. (Ephesians 6:4) 
  • Do not withhold discipline from a child; if you strike him with a rod, he will not die. If you strike him with the rod, you will save his soul from Sheol (hell). (Proverbs 23: 13-14) 
  • And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength. These words, which I am commanding you today, shall be on your heart. And you shall repeat them diligently to your sons and speak of them when you sit in your house, when you walk on the road, when you lie down, and when you get up. You shall also tie them as a sign to your hand, and they shall be as frontlets on your forehead. You shall also write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates. (Deuteronomy 6:5-9) 
The word discipline in the verses above comes from two Greek words. The Greek word paideia, which is the form found in Ephesians 6:4, refers to the training and education of children, the training and care of the body, instruction which aims to increase virtue, and chastisement for wrongdoing. The other word, which is found in most of the verses about discipline in Proverbs, is the Greek word muwcar, which refers exclusively to correction and chastisement and its use speaks very pointedly about discipline in light of not allowing children to get away with their sin. 

Everything that goes against the standard set by God is sin. Everything. Whether it is intentional or comes from past trauma or not. In the adoption world, it is common to refer to extreme behaviors as “survival behaviors.” If you break it down, most sins we commit are survival behaviors based on the belief that we cannot trust that God means what He says. Your child stealing a piece of candy at school because he doesn’t trust that anyone is going to feed him that day is a survival behavior, just like a woman who has an abortion because she cannot trust that God will provide everything she and her baby need is a survival behavior. That term may be appropriate to describe why someone is doing something but describing it that way in no way negates the spiritual ramifications of such actions. In order to know how to combat what it is that our children are doing, we have to be honest about what it is. Survival behaviors, when they go against the law of God, are sin. 

Dangerous ideologies 

I want to specifically spend time refuting the first two ideologies I listed at the beginning, which I think are the most pervasive as we attempt to become well-versed in trauma-based parenting or parenting in general. The first idea was “You aren’t modeling God’s love and grace if you are unyielding in your expectations for your child’s behavior.” If we are professing to be Christians and want our children to do the same, yet their earthly mirror of God’s authority (us) is constantly giving “love and grace” and never requiring obedience, we are teaching them to believe that the same is true about God. John says it this way about those who say they know God, but do not obey God: 

And by this we know that we have come to know Him, if we keep His commandments. Whoever says “I know Him” but does not keep His commandments is a liar, and the truth is not in him, but whoever keeps His word, in him truly the love of God is perfected. (1 John 2: 3-5) 

Christian parents are often so focused on showing God’s grace and mercy to their children that they forget that we are recipients of God’s grace which He bestowed on us as a result of our repentance for sin, not in lieu of our repentance for sin. If we do not confess our sin and repent, we do not receive the grace of God. The grace that is given without repentance and obedience is a false grace! True grace is manifested in our home in the same way that true grace is manifested from God. God does not forgo the earthly consequences for sin because we are followers of Him. No, the earthly consequences for our sin are still enforced for believers. Yet, He has taken the burden of the eternal consequences of sin on Himself, and though we are sinners, He sees us as the righteousness of His Son, Jesus. 

Ladies, likewise, you will love and protect and provide for your child no matter if they get an F on their report card, whether they hit the dog, wet themselves on purpose, or lash out at you each day. You will never stop caring for them despite these tough behaviors. But excusing them as something that can’t be helped because of the trauma they’ve been through and not following through with discipline and correction that means something to them and enacts change in their lives is not love and grace. Some of us are spinning our wheels, trying the same things with our kids every day, going easy on them when it comes to punishment and making excuses for why our kids are still behaving badly years after joining our family. All the while, we are saying that we are modeling the grace of God for them. See what the Scripture says about delivering our children from the consequences of their actions: 

Discipline your son, for there is hope; do not set your heart on putting him to death. A hot-tempered man will pay the penalty, for if you deliver him, you will only have to do it again. (Proverbs 19:18-19) 

When we spare our children from the consequences of their actions or we don’t enforce any punishment when our children are disobedient, we will only have to keep doing it. They will not learn to do right, unless God brings in someone else to teach them. God has positioned us so as to be His vessel of instruction for our children. Don’t parent in such a way that God must choose to raise up someone else to do it because we neglected our responsibility. When we neglect to discipline our children, we are actually allowing them to develop a dangerous worldview, thinking that they will not ever face the consequences of their actions, and ultimately we are securing their death, potentially in an earthly and eternal sense, unless God intervenes in their lives in another way. 

The second ideology I specifically want to refute is the idea that “Kids misbehave because of the trauma they have experienced, and if they could make a better choice, they would. Therefore they don’t because they physiologically can’t.” It’s true, foster and adopted kids can’t choose to do the right thing on their own. Because they, like everyone else, are human. The Scriptures say that we are born sinners: Behold, I was brought forth in guilt, and in sin my mother conceived me. (Psalm 51:5) 

No matter if we were born to a godly family or an abusive one, we were still born in sin. The Scriptures say that without Christ, we have no choice but to sin: But thanks be to God that though you were slaves of sin, you became obedient from the heart to that form of teaching to which you were entrusted, and after being freed from sin, you became slaves to righteousness. (Romans 6:17-18) 

None of us, apart from Christ, can choose not to sin. We can and should help our children practice good choices by making it more desirable for them to do right than to do wrong. We also can and should teach them the truth about God, sin, and salvation. However, even when they make the decision to follow Christ, they are not going to be without sin. Saying someone is physiologically unable to make a better choice is shortcutting the whole problem. We are all unequivocally unable to do good things without the power of God working in us. Also, by default, saying a child can’t make a right decision if their brains are wired a certain way or if they have experienced trauma is to blaspheme the mighty power of God, the Creator of their brains, to do the same miraculous work in them that He has done in us. For the Scriptures say, 

And I will give them one heart, and put a new spirit within them. And I will remove the heart of stone from their flesh and give them a heart of flesh, so that they may walk in My statutes, and keep My ordinances and do them. Then they will be My people, and I shall be their God. (Ezekiel 11: 19-20) 

God has created our children to be who He wants them to be and is fully capable of aligning their brains and their hearts to Himself if they surrender their lives to Him. That should be our focus in discipline. Not allowing sin without consequences. Not being a doormat to our children’s whims and wishes. If you have to miss the ball game because Jessie won’t put her shoes on, please miss the ball game. Please don’t allow her to call the shots. If she can put her shoes on in other situations, she can put them on when you ask her to. Judgment is coming one day for our children. I will be happy to edit this post if I find the Bible verse that says that people who came from traumatic upbringings will not face God’s anger and judgment for their sins. I am confident that I will not be making such an edit. Job 21:22-26 says, 

But who can teach a lesson to God since he judges even the most powerful? One person dies in prosperity, completely comfortable and secure, the picture of good health, vigorous and fit. Another person dies in bitter poverty, never having tasted the good life. But both are buried in the same dust, both eaten by the same maggots. 

The Bible says on more than one occasion that no one is exempt from judgment regardless of ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and here we see that even those who “never tasted the good life” are also going to face the same judgment. Our life on earth is not all there is. Your role as a parent has one purpose: to accurately model and teach your children the way of the Gospel of Jesus Christ so that they might surrender their lives to Him as well and make their eternity secure. As it says in Hebrews 9:27-28: 

And just as each person is destined to die once and after that comes judgment, so also Christ was offered once for all time as a sacrifice to take away the sins of many people. He will come again, not to deal with our sins, but to bring salvation to all who are eagerly waiting for him. 

Instead of becoming influenced by those who paint motherhood as our best cosmic opportunity to practice grace and love, neglecting truth and justice, we need to remember that our children are facing the same outcome as everyone else if they are not taught to understand that they are sinful and in need of Jesus as their Savior! 

We have been deceived 

Ladies, if you haven’t recently read 2 Timothy 3, stop right now and go read it. In it, Paul has a lot to say about how people will think and behave in the last days. It warns women to not fall prey to people who “have the appearance of godliness, but deny its power.” It tells us to stay away from those who “creep into households and capture weak women, burdened with sins and led astray by various passions, always learning and never able to arrive at a knowledge of the truth.” Paul says that people who do this “will not get very far, for their foolishness will be plain to all.” 

2 Timothy 3 also calls Christ-followers to “continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed, knowing from whom you learned it and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus.” It reminds us that “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.” 

When we are vulnerable to believe anything that we see from leaders that claim to be Christians, without examining what they’re saying against the whole Word of God, we are these weak women. We want what is best for our children, but we are sinful because we are not trusting God with their healing or to guide us to appropriate discipline through the study of His Word and the knowledge He allows us to have through others who have gone before us. Instead of taking useful strategies, thanking God, and applying them to what He has already told us to do, we are led astray by the leaders who have created entire movements based on a few good principles, turning instead to their social media pages, to their classes and teachings. We feel that we can never know enough about how to help our children because we do not believe that God’s system of discipline and instruction is sufficient. And as a result, our children are also carried away by excuses, in searching for what will make them whole. We have spent our lives looking for the solution to their trauma and as a result we have trained ourselves and our kids that God is not it. In fact, God is the one who teaches us through His infallible Word that He is the solution for every circumstance that belies us. His Word is helpful for teaching and correcting our kids, for training our entire family in the way of righteousness, and to equip us for every good work, including raising our kids. Our children can be complete by knowing God, knowing His Word and coming to salvation through Him. Any resources God brings to us from other humans, is simply that. A resource. Not a way of life. Not a worldview. Not a religion. We have all we need in Christ.

No comments:

Post a Comment